Application of 3D Printing Technology in the Development of Novel Drug Delivery Systems

Three-dimensional printing (3DP) is a unique prototyping technology that has advanced over the past 35 years and has the great potential to revolutionize the field of drug delivery with its inherent advantages of customizability and the ability to fabricate complex solid dosage forms with high accuracy and precision. 3DP can fabricate solid dosage forms with variable densities and diffusivities, complex internal geometries, multiple drugs and excipients. Literature data suggest many benefits of the 3DP technology over the conventional technologies in the field of novel drug delivery system (NDDS). 3DP can successfully address the issues relating to the drug delivery of poorly water-soluble drugs, peptides, potent drugs and the release of multi-drugs, etc. However, there are some problems that restrict the applications of 3DP in commercial market, such as the selections of suitable binders, excipients and the pharmaco-technical properties of final products. Further advancement in process performance is required to overcome these issues where 3DP technology can be successfully combined with NDDS. Here we present an overview and the potential of 3DP in the progress of new drug delivery systems. Maulvi FA, Shah MJ, Solanki BS, Patel AS, Soni TG, et al. (2017) Application of 3D Printing Technology in the Development of Novel Drug Delivery Systems. Int J Drug Dev & Res 9: 44-49 Volume 9(1): 44-49 (2017)-045 Int J Drug Dev & Res ISSN: 0975-9344 risk of new development to fail at later stages [31-33]. 3D printing in pharmaceutical industry represents a well-designed tool for designing simple, accurate, cheap, structured and tailored drug delivery systems [34-36]. This flexibility can offer many novel strategic approaches for the research and development of controlled-release drug delivery systems [37,38]. In the last 15 years (Table 1), a large variety of 3D printing techniques have been introduced into the rapid prototyping (RP) industry [39]. Gbureck et al. investigated the adsorption and desorption kinetics of antibiotics from microporous bioceramics (hydroxyapatite, brushite and monetite) fabricated by a novel low temperature 3D powder direct printing process as a drug delivery system. Vancomycin and ofloxacin were rapidly released into buffer media within 24-48 h, while tetracycline showed a sustained release for 5 days. Additional polymer impregnation of the drug loaded matrix with polylactic acid/ polyglycolic acid polymer solutions showed improved drug release kinetics [40]. Alvaro et al. demonstrated the feasibility of using fusedfilament 3D printer to fabricate drug-loaded tablets which showed sustained drug release profiles, which can be modified by careful selection of the printing parameters. Their results suggest that the 3D printer could offer a new potential method for manufacturing personalised-dose medicines [41]. They also formulated and developed modified-release drug loaded tablets containing 5-aminosalicylic acid (5-ASA, mesalazine) and 4-aminosalicylic acid (4-ASA) via a fused-deposition 3-dimensional printing (FDM 3DP) method with varying infill percentages, which demonstrate the feasibility of using 3D printer to fabricate drug-loaded tablets [42]. In another approach, they explored the feasibility of combining hot melt extrusion with 3D printing technology to formulate different shaped (cube, pyramid, cylinder, sphere and torus) paracetamol-loaded tablets which would be otherwise difficult to produce using conventional traditional methods [43]. Weidong et al. developed levofloxacin implants using a novel 3D printing technique based on a lactic acid polymer matrix with a predefined microstructure that is amenable to rapid prototyping and fabrication. The implant showed bi-modal profile displaying both pulsatile (day 5 to 25) and steady state drug release (day 25 to 50) from a single implant, the next pulse release phase then began at the 50th day Printing technology/Printer type Dosage forms/Systems Model drug used Reference 3D powder direct printing technology Microporous bioceramics Tetracycline, Vancomycin and Ofloxacin [40] Fused-filament 3D printing Tablets Fluorescein [41] 3D printer Tablets Paracetamol [43] 3D printer Complex oral dosage forms Fluorescein [45] 3D extrusion printer Multi-active solid dosage form (polypill) Aspirin, Hydrochlorothiazide Pravastatin, Atenolol & Ramipril [47] Piezoelectric inkjet printer Microparticles Paclitaxel [48] Fused deposition 3D printing Extended release tablet Prednisolone [49] 3D printer Tablet implant Isoniazide [51] 3D printer Doughnut-shaped multi-layered drug delivery device Acetaminophen [52] 3D printer Fast-disintegrating drug delivery device Paracetamol [53] Fused deposition 3D printer Oral pulsatile capsule Acetaminophen [54] 3D printer Fast disintegrating tablet Acetaminophen [56] 3D printer Oral pulsatile tablet Chlorpheniramine maleate & Diclofenac sodium [22] Ink-jet printer Solid dispersion Felodipine [59] Desktop 3D printer Bi-layer matrix tablet Guaifenesin [46] Laboratory scale 3-DPTM machine Capsule with immediate release core and a release rate regulating shell Pseudoephedrine hydrochloride [50] Fused deposition 3D printer Modified-release drug loaded tablet 5-Aminosalicylic acid & 4-Aminosalicylic acid [42] Extrusion-based printer Multi-active tablets (Polypill) Captopril, Nifedipine & Glipizide [65] 3D printer Complex matrix tablet with ethylcellulose gradients Acetaminophen [57] Inkjet printer Implant with lactic acid polymer matrix Levofloxacin [44] 3D printer Multi-layered concentric implant Rifampicin and Isoniazid [55] Micro-drop Inkjet 3DP Nanosuspension Folic Acid [70] Thermal Inkjet printer Dosing drug Solutions onto oral films Salbutamol sulphate [71] Commercial inkjet printer Nanocomposite structure Rifampicin and Calcium phosphate [72] 3D Extrusion printer Drug encapsulated film of PLGA and PVA Dexamethasone [61] Thermal Inkjet printer Oral solid dosage forms Prednisolone [73] 3D printer Microfluidic pump Saline solution [74] Stereolithography printer Anti-acne patch Salicylic acid [66] 3D printer Biodegradable patch 5-Fluorouracil [67] Fused deposition 3D printer Immediate release tablets 5-Aminosalicylic acid, Captopril, Theophylline & Prednisolone [68] Fused-deposition printer T-shaped intrauterine systems and subcutaneous rods Indomethacin [69] Electro hydrodynamic atomization technique Patterned micron scaled structures Tetracycline hydrochloride [75] Fused deposition printer Capsules for immediate and modified release Acetaminophen and Furosemide [76] 3D printer Biofilm disk Nitrofurantoin [77] Multi-nozzle 3D printer Capsule-shaped solid devices Acetaminophen & Caffeine [62] Fused-deposition printer Capsule-shaped tablets Budesonide [63] Stereolithographic 3D printer Modified-release tablets 4-aminosalicylic acid & Paracetamol [64] Table 1: Summary of 3-Dimensional printing technologies applied in the development of pharmaceutical drug delivery systems. Maulvi FA, Shah MJ, Solanki BS, Patel AS, Soni TG, et al. (2017) Application of 3D Printing Technology in the Development of Novel Drug Delivery Systems. Int J Drug Dev & Res 9: 44-49 Volume 9(1): 44-49 (2017)-046 Int J Drug Dev & Res ISSN: 0975-9344 and ended up to 80th day [44]. Katstra et al. manufactured oral dosage forms by 3D printing technology which showed excellent content uniformity and dosage control than conventional mixing and pressing techniques [45]. Shaban et al. developed guaifenesin bi-layer tablets using 3D printing technology, which satisfied the requirements of regulatory standards and matches with the release of standard commercial tablets [46]. They also used 3D extrusion printer to manufacture a multi-active solid dosage form (polypill), were the complex medication regimes can be combined in a single personalised tablet. The polypill contain an immediate release compartment for aspirin and hydrochlorothiazide and three sustained release compartments containing pravastatin, atenolol, and ramipril [47]. Byung et al. used a piezoelectric inkjet printing system to fabricate paclitaxel-loaded poly (lactic-co-glycolic acid) polymer microparticles with well-defined and controlled shapes. The microparticles showed a biphasic release profile with an initial burst due to diffusion and subsequent sustained release due to degradation of polymer. The release rate was dependent on the geometry, mainly the surface area, with a descending rate order of honeycomb>grid, ring>circle [48]. Skowyra et al. investigated the feasibility of using a fused deposition modelling based 3D printer to fabricate extended release tablet using prednisolone loaded poly (vinyl alcohol) filaments. The methodology showed highly adjustable, affordable, minimally sized, digitally controlled platform for producing patient-tailored medicines [49]. Wang et al. developed zero-order controlled-release pseudoephedrine hydrochloride formulations using 3-D technology. Mixtures of Kollidon SR and hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose were used as drug carriers [50]. Gui et al. fabricated sustained released isoniazide NH/ Poly-L-lactic acid tablet implant via 3D printing technique for topical drug delivery [51]. Deng et al. developed novel doughnut-shaped multi-layered acetaminophen delivery devices by varying drug and release-retardant material to provide linear release profiles. Based on computer-aided design models, different devices containing acetaminophen, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose as matrix and ethyl cellulose (EC) as a release-retardant material were prepared automatically using a three-dimensional printing (3DP) system [52]. They also fabricated novel fast-disintegrating drug delivery devices with special inner structure characteristics using 3D printers [53]. Melocchi et al. fabricated capsular device for oral pulsatile release based on a erodible hydroxypropyl cellulose using fused deposition modeling 3D printer [54]. Weigang et al. fabricated a programmed release multi-drug implant for bone tuberculosis therapy using 3D printers. The drug implant was a multi-layered concentric cylinder divided into four layers from the center to the periphery. Isoniazid and rifampicin were distributed individually into the different layers in a specific sequence of isoniazidrifampicin-isoniazid-rifampicin. The in-vitro and in-vivo release data showed that the isoniazid and rifampicin were released orderly from outside to the center to form a multi-drug therapeutic alliance [55]. Deng et al. fabricated a novel fast disintegrating tablet using computer-aided models (3D printer) to have control over the material composition, microstructure, and surface texture [56]. They also fabricated complex tablets with zero-order drug release characteristics using 3D printer. The matrix tablets with 68% drug weight exhibited material gradients in radial direction with drug-free release-barrier layers on both the sides. In vitro results showed linear release up to 12 h, through two-dimensional surface erosion mechanism [57]. Rowe et al. fabricated many different types of complex oral drug delivery devices using 3D printers, including pulsed release of chlorpheniramine maleate which occurred after a lag time of 10 min, followed by extended release up to 7 h. Breakaway erodible tablets composed of three sections, an interior fast-eroding section separated by two drug-releasing sub-units which erode in 30-45 min in simulated gastric fluid. An enteric dual pulsatory tablet composed of diclofenac sodium was printed into two separated areas. All formulations showed promising results in in-vitro drug release studies [58]. To control the release of drug, Nikolaos et al. fabricated felodipine solid dispersion using polyvinyl pirrolidone by inkjet printer [59]. Natalja et al. fabricated controlled-release oral dosage forms by printing drugs on porous model carriers using inkjet printing technology with flexographic printers. The technology added the advantage of accurate dosing and tailored drug delivery according to dosage requirements [60]. To control the drug release profile, Parawee et al. used a novel extrusion printing system to encapsulate dexamethasone salt within a biodegradable polymer (PLGA) and water soluble poly (vinyl alcohol) (PVA). The in vitro studies showed minor burst release with sustained release up to 4 months [61]. Alvaro et al. used multi-nozzle 3D printer to fabricate capsuleshaped solid devices loaded with multiple drugs (Acetaminophen and Caffeine) [62]. They also used fused deposition printing technology with hot melt extrusion and fluid bed coating to develop modifiedrelease budesonide dosage forms [63]. The team also showed the use of stereolithographic 3D printer to fabricate 4-aminosalicylic acid and paracetamol-loaded tablets to tailor the drug release profiles [64]. Shaban et al. used extrusion-based printing technology to fabricate multi-active tablets (Polypill) containing 3 drugs molecules (Captopril, Nifedipine and Glipizide) to treat patients suffering from diabetics and hypertension [65]. Deng et al. developed complex matrix tablet with ethylcellulose gradients to achieve zero-order acetaminophen release using 3D printing processes. The tablet showed linear drug release via a two-dimensional surface erosion mechanism up to 12 h [57]. Alvaro et al. developed salicylic acid patches to treat acne using stereolithography printer. The patch showed high drug loading with release rate of 291 μg/cm2 for 3 h, without drug degradation [66]. Gyeong et al. introduced novel 3D-printed patches which composed of a blend of poly (lactide-co-glycolide), polycaprolactone, and 5-fluorouracil to deliver the anti-cancer drug in a sustained manner for 4 weeks. The 3D printing technique provides a versatile shape to the biodegradable patch to be administered at the exact tumor site [67]. Muzna et al. demonstrated a reproducible approach based on pharmaceutical grade non-melting filler which allowed a consistent flow from printer’s nozzle to facilitate 3D printed tablets using Eudragit as a polymer filament with four different physiological drugs entrapped. The fabricated immediate release tablets possessed excellent mechanical strength and acceptable in-batch variations [68]. Natalja et al. investigated the printability of different grades of ethylene vinyl acetate copolymers for fused-deposition modeling based 3D printing technology to fabricate T-shaped intrauterine systems and subcutaneous rods to deliver drugs up to 30 days [69]. Challenges in 3D printing technology Although 3D printing technology showed promising results in drug delivery applications, the technology is still under the developing stage. The challenges include optimization of the process, improving performance of device for versatile use, selections of appropriate excipients, post treatment method, etc., need to be addressed to improve the 3D printed products’ performance and to expend the application range in novel drug delivery systems. Maulvi FA, Shah MJ, Solanki BS, Patel AS, Soni TG, et al. (2017) Application of 3D Printing Technology in the Development of Novel Drug Delivery Systems. Int J Drug Dev & Res 9: 44-49 Volume 9(1): 44-49 (2017)-047 Int J Drug Dev & Res ISSN: 0975-9344 Drop-on-demand (DoD) printer heads which are most commonly used in 3D printing technology showed major limitation of nozzle clogging. The binder gets dried up if not frequently used (or improper washing). Also in case of ballistic ejection, agglomeration of fine powder restricts the application in drug delivery [70-78]. The use of electrostatic and acoustic (DoD) print head designs are still in the developing stage [79]. Fluid handling systems are quite complex in continuous jet (CJ) printer, although it allows freedom from nozzle clogging and the use of volatile solvents [32]. To achieve quality 3DP products, the chemistry of binder and formulation need to be addressed. The selected binder in 3DP process should be compatible with the printer head components. Also control over surface tension and viscosity of binder solution is important to achieve stable droplet formation [9]. To apply 3DP for drug delivery, it is mandatory to study the rheological properties of binder solution, especially when high-molecular-weight polymers are involved in dosage forms [80]. In powder deposition technique, polymers must be present in fine particles for 3DP process. Thus the polymer which can be processed in fine particles can only be used in 3DP technology [39]. Stair stepping problem need to be addressed in powder deposition technique [81]. To achieve quality 3DP products, many important parameters need to be optimized like printing rate, printing passes, line velocity of the print head, interval time between two printing layer, distance between the nozzles and the powder layer, etc. [82,83]. It is also important to consider post process after prototyping like drying (hot air heat, microwaves and infrared) methods, as it has major impact on the quality of the finished 3DP products [84-86]. To increase the drug loading capacity in 3DP processed tablet, uniaxial compression and suspension dispersed methodologies are adopted, but this technique suffer from increased complexity and clogging of spray nozzle [87,88]. To achieve precise 3D configuration, high spatial resolution and desirable drug release profile, bleeding must be controlled in printing process. Thus a thorough understanding of powder binder interaction, powder dissolution, re-solidification and evaporation rate of binder liquid is required to control bleeding [57,89-91].